• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Gaby's Bakery Shop: A Hidden Gem of Delightful Treats in Brooklyn

At Gaby's Bakery Shop, nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, a passion for authentic baked goods shines through. This unassuming gem specializes in traditional Mexican flavors, offering a delightful array of treats from the ultra-moist Tres Leches cake to irresistible donuts. Each creation reflects a commitment to quality, with fresh ingredients ensuring rich textures and balanced sweetness, perfect for any occasion. Customers rave about the generous slice sizes and the overall value, making it the go-to spot for satisfying dessert cravings. Gaby's embodies a warm, inviting atmosphere where every visit feels like a special celebration of flavor and tradition.

Gaby's Bakery Shop at a glance

  • Address 238 Knickerbocker Ave Brooklyn, NY 11237
  • Phone (718) 418-8821
  • Restaurant type Bakery .

Photos & Gallery

Gaby's Bakery Shop: Reviews & Ratings

Jennifer MacFarlane
5

These guys are absolute geniuses. Honestly, the best tres leches cake I’ve ever had in my entire life. I’m telling you that this is Brooklyn’s best kept secret. Luis is a master Baker.

A Z
5

Someone on Reddit said this tres leches cake is the "most moist mouthful" of cake he/she had. Person's right though bc this cake was HEAVY. Milk was also oozing out the bottom of the cake. It was a tad bit TOO moist for me but this cake was soooo gooooood

Beatriz Gutierrez
5

We order our cakes for quinceañera's & regular birthdays here. The cakes taste delicious. Family favorites are chocoflan, tres leches with fruit & coffee flavor with nuts. They deliver the cakes for a fee. Haven't had a problem with orders .

Leo D
5

The only thing I’ve tried at this place is their tres leche (three milk) cakes and I’ve been in love with them ever since!! Perfect amount of sweetness, affordable ($5 for a big slice), and moist. The only con I’ve ever had is the fruit tres leches, like the strawberry, can get a bit old quickly but that’s natural with natural cakes like this. 10/10 will eat again - and I always do!

Tania V.
5

I love going for their small gelatin flowers. I think they make a great present for non Mexicans. And the staff are always friendly. Would recommend!

Jocelyne Nicole
5

Very helpful and attentive, at first I requested a hk cake shape of the cartoon figure only. She said they don’t make that but can attempt a different way which came out beautiful. It was delicious everyone enjoyed it

Roz A
5

I bought a coffee flavor cake and Mexican bread which were delicious. I gave a piece to my neighbors and they even asked where did I buy the cake from. They also have a variety of mexican products as well which is great. Employees are polite and helpful.

Mark LoGiurato
4

Great bakery to get hispanic pastries and the like.

Location

  • Gaby's Bakery Shop
    Gaby's Bakery Shop
    238 Knickerbocker Ave Brooklyn, NY 11237 Hotline: (718) 418-8821

Welcome to Gaby's Bakery Shop, a charming hidden gem located at 238 Knickerbocker Ave in Brooklyn, NY. This unassuming bakery offers a delightful array of freshly baked treats that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. From rich tres leches cakes to delectable donuts, Gaby's Bakery Shop is a haven for those who appreciate quality baked goods served with a dash of local charm.

What sets Gaby's Bakery Shop apart? As you step inside, the enticing aroma of baked goods fills the air, beckoning you to explore the menu. The highlight here is undoubtedly their tres leches cake, which has been lauded by many customers. Reviewers rave about its moisture and balance of sweetness, with one noting it as perhaps the “most moist mouthful” they’ve ever experienced. At approximately $30 for an 8-9 inch cake, it's both an affordable and indulgent option for any occasion.

  • Flavors Galore: Whether you fancy a slice of the strawberry shortcake that melts in your mouth, or crave the nostalgic flavors of a classic pan mexicano, Gaby's has something for everyone.
  • Value: Priced reasonably with delights like donuts starting at just $2 and slices of cake for $4, it’s easy to see why local customers keep coming back.
  • Casual Vibe: The bakery offers a takeout option, making it convenient for those on the go, while also accepting credit cards and accommodating bike parking.

Despite a few quirky interactions noted by guests, the overwhelming consensus highlights the inviting nature of Gaby's baked goods rather than the staff dynamics. It’s a place that thrives on the quality of its products, allowing taste to override any minor inconveniences.

In conclusion, Gaby's Bakery Shop is a must-visit for anyone in Brooklyn looking for deliciously fresh and affordable baked goods. With its diverse offerings and consistent quality, it’s no wonder customer reviews glow with positivity. So make your way to Gaby’s and treat yourself to a slice of cake or perhaps a donut—you won’t be disappointed!

For more information, feel free to call them at (718) 418-8821 and get ready to indulge your sweet tooth!

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Accepts SNAP/EBT
    • Credit cards